Vice President JD Vance. Official Portrait.
With the 2026 midterms already in the books, it's probably time to stop analyzing the past and start looking at the future. Obviously, the midterms were not good for the ruling Republican Party and a lot of soul searching is going on to figure out what happened. But instead of obsessing over what happened, it might be useful to think about what is next.
I do view the 2028 election as one that is winnable. It will require a course correction from both the Republican Party and the Trump Administration. This was an anger election and the conditions that launched it were temporary. Folks are angry about the Iran war and I doubt that will be a concern two years from now.
Of course, the critical question is who do the Republicans put up as a candidate. Donald Trump, who has dominated Republican politics for more than a decade, will no longer be able to run. Who picks up that mantle? Will it be another MAGA candidate? Will it be a milquetoast moderate? Someone not connected to the administration? Someone opposed to the administration?
JD Vance:
JD Vance is the obvious potential candidate. He's relatively popular and many of the MAGA faithful love him. Critically, he was an internal vote of opposition to the Iran conflict and can be counted on to support MAGA tentpole issues like immigration. He's also young enough that he might appeal to young voters.
But he has some obvious downsides. First of all, he might not want to run. He's got a very young family and might not want spend his kids childhoods working the most stressful job in the world. He's also got some major liability with who he choses to associate with, Vivek Ramaswamy is a close personal friend and that does not reflect well on Vance. Plus, at a time when immigrants from India is one of the most hot button issues in all of North America, he's married to one and his best friend is one. This is probably a bigger deal than anyone is willing to admit.
Marco Rubio:
Rubio is one of the harder working members of the Trump administration and his foreign policy credentials can't be denied. He's well liked among MAGA and the fact that he is Hispanic might bring back some Hispanic and Latino voters that turned left this year.
Rubio has some issues as well, and I think he's actually a better VP candidate than Presidential one. Rubio is a foreign policy wonk at a time where Americans aren't in favor of GOP foreign policy, to say the least. He has some of the taint of the Iran conflict on him.
But the real problem? Rubio is bad at debates. Trump wiped the floor with him in 2016, but that's because he's a good debater. But losing to Chris Christie? I said after that debate that Rubio's presidential ambitions were done at that point, and I don't think I am wrong. It's possible he's advanced since then, but I don't see it.
Ron DeSantis:
DeSantis has been a credible presidential candidate for a couple cycles now and nobody can deny he's done an extremely good job in Florida. Indeed, he's got a lot to do with Florida being a swing state, to being one of the most solid red states in the country. He's extremely competent and low drama for the most point and has been free of scandals. There's a very good argument for voting for someone who can get things done, and it's very clear that DeSantis has got a ton of things done in Florida.
But will voters forgive him for not supporting President Trump as much as he could? Possibly, but he was also everyone's 2nd choice in 2024 and 2020. The other problem is that he doesn't have any foreign policy experience and I have little knowledge if he would be good in a debate.
Ted Cruz:
Cruz is a popular Senator and made a deep run in 2016. He's well known and fairly smart. He's good in a debate and eventually showed a lot of loyalty to President Trump.
But I don't see him as a serious candidate. Yes, he's well known, but a lot of people on both sides dislike him. Trump joked that he could nominate him for SCOTUS and he would pass because both parties would vote for him just to get rid of him because they all hate him, and that's probably accurate. Some folks won't forgive him for not dropping out in 2016 when it was clear that Donald Trump was going to be the candidate. And he's just an unlikable person, a President is someone you want to have a beer with (which is also why Kamala Harris lost), but would you really want to have a beer with Ted Cruz?
Rand Paul:
Rand Paul is popular among the libertarian wing of the Republican Party and he's at least has some credibility as a candidate. But I don't really view him as a credible candidate. The best I could see from him is an "also ran" candidacy that doesn't accomplish much.
Thomas Massie:
I have no idea why his name is even being floated given that he's out of congress in disgrace following a brutal primary race. I guess he appeals to the contrarian right that cares more about hating other Republicans than actually fighting Democrats or getting anything done, but I think it's pretty clear that he won't win. I think folks want someone more willing to work with people and Massie has always been the guy that makes perfect the enemy of good. Republican voters have already rejected him.
Glenn Youngkin:
This is the neocon "let's go back to before 2016" wing of the party candidate and I don't see him being successful. Youngkin was a good Governor of a swing state, but that was awhile ago, and you can't ignore the fact that he screwed up the election after he ended his term. There's an argument for running a boring candidate, but I think it's a bad one in this case. The Republicans don't need to go back to being the Washington Generals of elections, and I think going for Youngkin is a great way to do so.
Chris Christie:
No. He's not going to be the candidate. He's the RINO of all RINO's and the former governor of a blue state and has those same blue state values. He's a good debater, to be sure, but that's about it. Vivek Ramaswamy (who nobody is mentioning as a candidate this time around) has a better chance than Christie.
So who is it going to be? My guess is probably Ron DeSantis. Vance might not run and he might not win if he does. Rubio might decide that a 2032 or 2036 run would be a better idea. But DeSantis is far enough away from Trump that the Trump haters will vote for him, but close enough to him that MAGA voters will go for him too. It could easily be Vance or Rubio, but that's going to depend on how well things go in the 2nd half of Trump's 2nd term. If it goes well, they could be well positioned, but if it doesn't, DeSantis is a shoe-in.
The rest of the candidates? I don't really see any of them being credible candidates and if they do run, I doubt any of them break 10%. There is a possibility that some other darkhorse candidate could pop up, but who? I just don't see who else it could be besides one of the main three, Vance, Rubio and DeSantis.