Amy Acton in Ohio. AP.
Vivek Ramaswamy (R) released an extremely controversial advertisement targeting his opponent Amy Acton (D) in a hotly contested Governor's race in Ohio. AP. The advertisement featured Acton's birth mother, Donna Arthur, who claimed that Acton lied about claims of living in poverty as a child. However, Acton was estranged from her mother after her Stepfather was arrested and indicted for sexually abusing her as a 12 year old child. Arthur stood by the stepfather, Cledith Arthur, and fled with him after he jumped bail and lived as a fugitive from justice until his death in 2004. Acton's father won custody and she has been estranged with her mother since then. Ramaswamy's campaign eventually took credit for the advertisement and will broadcast it as well. The ad has been condemned by figures on both the left and right.
My Comment:
This is one of the biggest own goals I have seen in a political race in recent history. It's right up there with Biden's debate performance or Michael Dukakis riding that tank. I just have no idea what Ramaswamy is thinking here and why he thinks this is going to somehow help his campaign. Indeed, at this point, if I lived in Ohio I would not vote for him. I wouldn't vote for Acton either, but I just don't think that someone with political instincts this bad should be governor.
Though Arthur didn't directly say that Acton lied about her abuse, the implication was there. And I have little doubt that she was abused. To be fair, the case was never tried in court, but the fact that Cledith Arthur fled the state instead of facing charged, living as a fugitive until he died, is a strong argument that it happened. And the case was strong enough that an indictment happened. Plus, Acton's brother, corroborated her story. It's a much stronger case than, for example, the Cornel 7 incident. I would say that the allegations are more likely than not to be true, and that's a hell of a thing to risk a campaign on!
And even if the allegations were false, so what? It's ancient history at this point and digging it up to score some political points is not going to play well. It's such a personal issue that wasn't really a factor in anything to begin with, that it risks giving Acton sympathy that she wouldn't otherwise deserve. Yeah, you might get some points if you could absolutely prove that she is a liar, but that didn't happen here! But even if it had, it's still incredibly ugly.
But the allegations seem true, so that makes this look even worse! Donna Arthur does not strike me as someone that should be trusted and the allegations are, at the very least, credible. So this just looks like an extremely low move for a campaign that looks desperate. It's going to turn a lot of people off and I would not be surprised if Acton wins because of it.
My objection here is that he's platforming someone who may have done something worse than lying about a sexual assault. Donna Arthur, by all appearances, let her husband molest her daughter and instead of protecting her, she stood by him. If that's what happened, she's an evil person. And, by my accounting it seems more likely than not that's exactly what happened! And Ramaswamy is using that to try and win an election.
I'm generally bullish on the GOP in 2026, at least compared to the polls, but the Ohio Governor's race was always primed for an upset due to Ramaswamy. Keep in mind, Ramaswamy had an uphill battle, largely because he picked a fight with MAGA over immigration. His famous crashout on X turned off a lot of folks that might otherwise support him. Plus, he is persona non grata among the Groypers for his race alone. I didn't like the guy after his New Year's crashout on X and I really wish he hadn't even run in the first place.
Candidate quality was always the problem in this race. Ramaswamy should have never won but the only other guy in the race was Casey Putsch, who famously also had a massive crashout on X. I actually had Putsch respond to me directly when I criticized both men for not being credible candidates, and honestly, knowing what I know now, I think I should have boosted him instead. Putsch was a bad candidate with bad political instincts, and I totally disagreed with him on subjects like Israel and the Epstein files, but I don't think he would have done this. Indeed, he claims he would not and went so far to endorse Acton. He would have been a terrible governor and would have likely lost to Acton too, but at least he wouldn't have done this.
I do think this is probably the end of Vivek Ramaswamy's political career. I don't see this advertisement helping him at all, and it will indeed hurt his chances. Again, it sure looks like he was pulling an extremely low political stunt and gives Acton ammo for being a better person than he is. I don't see how he recovers from this (unless the stunt somehow works) and any talk of him being a presidential candidate in 2028 are DOA.
My real concern is that Ramaswamy is so toxic that he could drag other Republicans down with him. Ohio has a competitive Senate race as well, and this could turn enough voters off that Jon Husted could be dragged down with him. That was always an objection I had to Ramaswamy, but it could even extend beyond Ohio. If I was the Democrats I'd run ads nationally about what Ramaswamy did here, and my guess is they might.


